Taming the Voice That Says You're Not Enough: My 20-Year Battle with the Inner Critic
The boardroom fell silent as I finished my presentation. I'd been preparing for weeks for this moment—pitching our executive team on a complete overhaul of our customer experience strategy. As our CEO opened his mouth to respond, my inner voice went into overdrive:
"You've missed something obvious."
"They're about to expose how little you actually know."
"Why would they listen to you when Sarah has been here longer?"
Despite leading successful teams for over a decade, despite the months of research backing my proposal, despite my track record of results—in that moment, I felt like an absolute fraud waiting to be exposed.
Sound familiar? Apparently, I am not alone in experiencing impostor syndrome, self doubt and adverse inner critic. Our Linkedin Poll revealed that at least another 1448 professionals shared similar day to day experiences!
The Unexpected Confession
Two weeks after that presentation (which, by the way, received unanimous approval), I was having coffee with our CFO, Michael. I'd always seen him as the embodiment of executive confidence—decisive, articulate, seemingly unshakable.
"I don't know how you do it," I said. "Present with such conviction."
Michael laughed, then leaned in. "Can I tell you something I've never shared with the team?" He described sitting in his car before board meetings, sometimes for 20 minutes, battling waves of inadequacy. "I've been waiting for them to realize they hired the wrong person. For fifteen years."
That conversation was a revelation. If Michael—whose leadership I deeply admired—struggled with these same demons, maybe this wasn't about individual inadequacy. Maybe it was about being human in roles that demand constant growth and adaptation.
The Inner Critic: Your Brain's Misguided Protector
I've spent years researching this phenomenon, both through formal study and personal experience coaching executive teams. What I've discovered is that the inner critic isn't a character flaw—it's a neurological response to perceived threat.
Dr. Amelia Richardson, a neuroscientist I interviewed for my research, explained it this way: "When we push beyond familiar territory, our brain's limbic system activates to protect us from potential harm. That protection often manifests as self-doubt designed to keep us in our 'safe' zone."
The problem? Leadership requires constantly venturing beyond that zone.
For women and underrepresented groups in leadership, this effect compounds. Research from MIT's Leadership Center found that when you're "the only one" in the room (the only woman, the only person of color, etc.), the brain's threat response intensifies, making the inner critic even louder.
Understanding this mechanism was my first step toward freedom. My self-doubt wasn't a unique personal failing—it was my brain's misguided attempt at protection.
Five Strategies That Actually Worked for Me (And My Clients)
Through personal experience and working with dozens of executives, I've found five approaches that create lasting change in our relationship with self-doubt. These aren't quick fixes—they're practice areas that build the mental muscle needed to lead with authentic confidence.
1. Create Evidence That Challenges Your Inner Narrative
After my conversation with Michael, I started what I call a "Reality Check" file. It's a simple document where I record:
Specific feedback that contradicts my self-doubt
Quantifiable achievements and contributions
Challenges I've overcome that once seemed impossible
For example, when my inner critic whispered, "You're not strategic enough for this role," I could counter with documented evidence: the successful market expansion I led, positive feedback from our CEO about my vision, the strategic framework I developed that increased revenue by 32%.
A practice to try: At the end of each week, write down three specific contributions you made that proved your capability. Be detailed and factual. Review this list before situations that typically trigger self-doubt.
2. Recognize Your Inner Critic's "Voice" and Signals
Through mindfulness practice, I've learned to recognize exactly how my inner critic announces itself. For me, it starts with a subtle tightness in my chest, followed by rapid thoughts that always begin with "They're going to think..."
By recognizing these signals, I can catch the pattern before it escalates.
Elena, a VP I coached through a major career transition, discovered her inner critic always emerged as a knot in her stomach and thoughts beginning with "I should already know how to..." Once she identified this pattern, she created a specific response: "I'm not supposed to know everything. My job is to learn and adapt."
A practice to try: For one week, notice the physical sensations and specific thought patterns that accompany your self-doubt. Where do you feel it in your body? What phrases does it use? Creating this awareness makes the inner critic less powerful and more manageable.
3. Build a Truth-Telling Inner Circle
Perhaps the most transformative step I took was creating what I call my "Truth Council"—a small group of trusted colleagues who I've explicitly asked to provide honest reflection.
These aren't just cheerleaders. They're people who know me well enough to recognize when I'm selling myself short and brave enough to call me on it. My council includes a former boss, two peers, and a direct report who's now become a close friend.
When I find myself questioning my abilities, I reach out to one of them with a simple question: "Am I seeing this situation clearly?" Their external perspective cuts through the distortion of self-doubt.
A practice to try: Identify 3-5 people whose judgment you trust implicitly. Ask if they'd be willing to serve as occasional "reality checkers" when your perception feels distorted by self-doubt. Be specific about what you need from them (honest feedback, not just reassurance).
4. Discover Your Unique Leadership Voice
One of my biggest breakthroughs came from recognizing that my leadership effectiveness didn't come from mimicking others. Early in my career, I tried to adopt the commanding presence of our previous director, feeling inadequate because my more collaborative style seemed "soft" in comparison.
A 360-degree review revealed something surprising: my team valued precisely what I considered weaknesses. My ability to listen deeply, synthesize diverse perspectives, and create psychological safety wasn't a leadership deficiency—it was my unique strength.
James, a tech executive I mentored, had a similar revelation. After years of trying to match his predecessor's charismatic, visionary style, he discovered his analytical, methodical approach created the stability his team desperately needed during a turbulent period.
A practice to try: Ask five colleagues to share the specific value you bring to the table that others don't. Look for patterns in their responses. These patterns often reveal your distinctive leadership voice—the very qualities your inner critic may be dismissing.
5. Transform Vulnerability Into Connection
Perhaps the most counterintuitive strategy I've discovered is the power of strategic vulnerability. For years, I believed leadership required projecting unwavering confidence. Admitting uncertainty or struggle seemed dangerous.
Then I watched our CEO handle a major product failure. Instead of defensive posturing, she openly acknowledged what went wrong, shared what she'd learned, and outlined a path forward. The result? Trust in her leadership actually increased.
Taking a cue from her example, I began experimenting with appropriate vulnerability—sharing challenges I was working through, admitting when I didn't have all the answers, asking for input rather than pretending to know everything.
To my surprise, this didn't diminish my authority. It humanized me and created deeper connection with my team. More importantly, it freed me from the exhausting pretense of perfection that had been feeding my inner critic.
A practice to try: In your next team meeting, identify one appropriate opportunity to say, "I don't have that answer yet, but I'm committed to finding it." Notice how this honest response feels compared to the pressure of having all the answers.
What Confidence Really Looks Like
After fifteen years in leadership roles, I've come to a realization that would have surprised my younger self: true confidence isn't the absence of self-doubt—it's the ability to act despite it.
Every leader I admire still battles their inner critic. The difference is they've developed a healthier relationship with that voice. They can hear it without being controlled by it. They can acknowledge doubt without being paralyzed by it.
Last month, as I prepared to speak at an industry conference—still feeling butterflies and hearing whispers of "Who are you to speak on this topic?"—I realized how different my response has become. Instead of being consumed by the doubt, I now see it as a familiar companion on the journey of growth.
I take a deep breath, review my "Reality Check" file, reach out to a member of my Truth Council, and remember that the voice isn't reality—it's just one perspective, and often a flawed one.
Then I step on stage and speak anyway.
Your Turn: A Reflection
I'm curious: How does your inner critic speak to you? What specific phrases does it use? And more importantly, what's one small step you could take this week to challenge its authority?
P.S. 🚀 Ready for Transformative Growth in Your Leadership?
Having guided over 1,330 women through their personal evolution, I help high-achieving leaders and entrepreneurs reimagine what's possible.
Book your complimentary 20-minute Leadership Breakthrough Session where we'll:
• Uncover the hidden EQ patterns holding you back
• Design your personalized leadership roadmap
• Create strategies to lead with compassion, confidence and authenticity
• Explore how private coaching can accelerate your growth
Limited spots available - only 3 breakthrough sessions offered per week.